Japanese Vinyl Pie Guy vs Bat Boy: Which Colorway to Collect?
By Super7 | Action Figures & Collectible Toys | Published: 2026-11-03
Category: Comparisons
Pie Guy in red or Bat Boy in yellow? Compare price, paintwork, and edition size on the supplied facts to decide which Super7 Japanese Vinyl figure fits your shelf.
Quick answer
Choose Pie Guy in red if you want a lower-cost, dessert-themed entry into Super7 Japanese Vinyl; choose Bat Boy in yellow if you value handmade, hand-painted sofubi and a documented limited release from NYCC 2019. Both are limited-edition Japanese Vinyl figures made in Japan, so the decision comes down to budget, paintwork, and how much the edition story matters to you.
The real trade-off: price and paintwork
Pie Guy in red is cast in red vinyl, which means the base color comes from the material itself rather than from paint. That keeps the figure at a lower catalog price and gives it a clean, uniform look. Bat Boy in yellow is handmade and hand-painted, so each piece carries slight variation and a more layered finish. The trade-off is straightforward: Pie Guy is the easier, cheaper way into Japanese vinyl sofubi, while Bat Boy asks for more budget in exchange for hand-finished detail and a specific release history.
Edition size and release story
Both figures are described as limited-edition Japanese Vinyl, but only Bat Boy carries an origin note: it was originally released for NYCC 2019 and is listed as very limited quantities available. Pie Guy is part of the Kandy Kaiju dessert gang and is also limited-edition, yet the supplied catalog does not state a production run or release year. If a documented convention release matters to your collection, Bat Boy has the clearer story; if you simply want a limited Japanese Vinyl figure at a lower price, Pie Guy is the practical pick.
Display and theme fit
Pie Guy's whipped-cream mustache and dessert theme make it a natural fit for a colorful, playful shelf. Bat Boy's 6-inch scale and yellow speckled finish give it more presence as a standalone display piece. Neither figure comes with supplied accessories or articulation details, so plan your display around the sculpt and color rather than play features.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Budget: Pie Guy lists at USD 18.50 against a USD 25.00 comparison price; Bat Boy lists at USD 41.60 against USD 65.00. Pie Guy costs less than half as much at catalog price. Set a per-figure budget before you choose; the gap is large enough to fund a second entry-level figure.
- Paintwork: Pie Guy is cast in red vinyl, so the color is in the material. Bat Boy is handmade and hand-painted, so expect slight differences between individual pieces. If you dislike variation between pieces, the cast-in-color Pie Guy is the safer pick.
- Edition story: Bat Boy has a documented NYCC 2019 origin and is listed as very limited quantities available. Pie Guy is limited-edition but the catalog does not state a run size or release year. Ask the store for remaining stock if edition size is your deciding factor.
Product facts
- Super7 Japanese Vinyl - Pie Guy (Red): Pie Guy is cast in red vinyl as part of the Kandy Kaiju dessert gang. The cast-in-color approach keeps the figure affordable and gives it a consistent red finish without painted wear.
Super7 Japanese Vinyl - Pie Guy (Red) - Japanese Vinyl - Bat Boy (Yellow): Bat Boy is a 6-inch yellow speckled vinyl figure, handmade and hand-painted in Japan, originally released for NYCC 2019. Hand-painted production means small variations between pieces, and the NYCC 2019 origin gives it a documented release story.
Japanese Vinyl - Bat Boy (Yellow)
Who should choose which
Best for
- Collectors new to Super7 Japanese Vinyl who want a low-cost first figure
- Fans of dessert-themed or Kandy Kaiju characters
- Buyers who prefer a clean cast-in-color finish over hand-painted variation
Not for
- Collectors who specifically want hand-painted sofubi with visible brushwork
- Buyers who need a documented convention release or known edition size
- Shoppers looking for a larger 6-inch display piece
